Correction (Jul 27, 2020, 1700h Pacific): an earlier version of this article erroneously stated that Canada used the USMCA to update its rules on TPMs; while there were proposed rule changes, they were not adopted. We regret the error.
Download all the posts in this series as a single PDF.
Today, the Electronic Frontier Foundation joins a coalition of international organizations in publishing an open letter of opposition to Mexico's new copyright law; the letter lays out the threats that Mexico's new law poses to fundamental human rights and calls upon Mexico's National Human Rights Commission to take action to invalidate this flawed and unsalvageable law.
In a rushed process without meaningful consultation or debate, Mexico's Congress has adopted a new copyright law modeled on the U.S. system, without taking any account of the well-publicized, widely acknowledged problems with American copyright law. The new law was passed as part of a package of legal reforms accompanying the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), Donald Trump's 2020 successor to 1989's North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).
However, Mexico's implementation of this Made-in-America copyright system imposes far more restrictions than either the USMCA demands or that Canada or the USA have imposed on themselves. This new copyright regime places undue burdens on Mexican firms and the Mexican people, conferring a permanent trade advantage on the richer, more developed nations of the USA and Canada, while undermining the fundamental rights of Mexicans guaranteed by the Mexican Constitution and the American Convention on Human Rights.
The opposition that sprang up after the swift passage of the new Mexican copyright law faces many barriers, but among the most serious ones is a disinformation campaign that (predictably) characterizes the claims about U.S. copyright law as "fake news". The EFF has more experience with the defects of U.S. copyright law than anyone, and in these coming days we will use it to explain in detail how Mexico's copyright law repeats and magnifies the errors that American lawmakers committed in 1998.
In 1998, the U.S. adopted the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), a law whose problems the US government has documented in exquisite detail in the decades since. By the U.S. government's own account, the DMCA presents serious barriers to:
- free expression;
- national resiliency;
- economic self-determination;
- the rights of people with disabilities;
- independent repair;
- access to knowledge; and
Despite these manifest defects, the U.S. government successfully pressured Canada into adopting substantially similar legislation in 2011 with the passage of Canada's Bill C-11.
In a series of posts over the coming days, we will elucidate the ways in which the Mexican copyright bill imposes undue and unique burdens on Mexico, Mexican people, and Mexican industry, and what lessons Mexico should have learned from the U.S. and Canadian experience with this one-sided, overreaching version of copyright for the digital world.
In 1998, the US tragically failed to see the import of getting the rules for the Internet right, passing a copyright law that treated the Internet as a glorified entertainment medium. When Canada adopted its law in 2011, it had no excuse for missing the fact that the Internet had become the world's digital nervous system, a medium where we transact our civics and politics; our personal, familial and romantic lives; our commerce and employment; our health and our education.
But these failings pale in comparison to the dereliction of Mexican lawmakers in importing this system to Mexico. The pandemic and its lockdown made it clear that everything we do not only involves the Internet: it requires the Internet. In today's world, it is absolutely inexcusable for a lawmaker to regulate the net as though it were nothing more than a glorified video-on-demand service.
Mexico's prosperity depends on getting this right. Even more: the human rights of the Mexican people require that the Congress of Mexico or the Mexican Court get this right.
Read the letter from EFF, Derechos Digitales and NGOs around the world to Mexico’s National Human Rights Commission here.
Other posts in this series:
- Download all the posts in this series as a single PDF
- How Mexico's New Copyright Law Crushes Free Expression
- Mexico's New Copyright Law: Cybersecurity and Human Rights
- Disability, Education, Repair and Health: How Mexico's Copyright Law Hurts Self-Determination in the Internet Age
- Mexico's New Copyright Law Undermines Mexico's National Sovereignty, Continuing Generations of Unfair "Fair Trade Deals" Between the USA and Latin America
- A Legal Deep Dive on Mexico’s Disastrous New Copyright Law