October 4, 2007 | By Kurt Opsahl

"No Good Lawyer" Would Buy Warrantless Surveillance Justification

Today the New York Times published a fascinating article about a secret government memo purporting to justify extreme interrogation methods, written even as the Administration was disavowing torture. The article is well worth a read in its own right. Deep within the article, lies an pagewanted=4&hp">anecdote on another topic ? the legal justifications for the NSA warrantless surveillance program:

An imposing former prosecutor and self-described conservative who
stands 6-foot-8, [Deputy Attorney General James B. Comey] was the
rare administration official who was willing to confront [Cheney's
Chief of Staff and Legal Counsel David] Addington. At one testy 2004
White House meeting, when Mr. Comey stated that "no lawyer" would
endorse [John] Yoo?s justification for the N.S.A. program, Mr.
Addington demurred, saying he was a lawyer and found it convincing.
Mr. Comey shot back: "No good lawyer," according to someone present.

Comey's comment comes as no surprise ? earlier this week Jack Goldsmith, former head of the Department of Justice?s Office of Legal Counsel, testified that when he took charge of the OLC and first saw the legal analysis of the warrantless surveillance, he "could not find the legal support for" aspects of the program, describing the justifications as ?a legal mess ... it was the biggest mess I encountered there."

Its time to put an end to the illegal surveillance. Call Congress today.


Deeplinks Topics

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

Want to use your skills for good? Join the @EFF team to help defend the Internet and your rights online
https://www.eff.org/about/opp...

Feb 24 @ 12:46pm

With TPP's defeat, copyright lobbyists beeline for RCEP, but scholars weigh in with a different view. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks...

Feb 24 @ 12:30pm

Have you renewed your EFF membership for this year? We could use your help. https://eff.org/renew

Feb 24 @ 12:09pm
JavaScript license information