December 3, 2004 | By Donna Wentworth

L'il Infringers

Our own Fred von Lohmann has a new column chronicling the misadventures of Marvel Comics as it seeks [PDF] to hold NCSoft Corp. and Cryptic Studios -- the operators of an online game called "City of Heroes" -- liable for the alleged copyright and trademark infringement of people who don virtual masks and "become" their favorite (Marvel) superheros.

Writes Fred:

Marvel's assertion of copyright and trademark rights over the noncommercial expressive activities of its fans is both unprecedented and unnecessary. The fundamental justification for copyright is that we must tolerate a limited statutory monopoly on expression in order to secure an adequate incentive for the creative industries. That's an adequate incentive, not the maximum conceivable incentive. ... Does anyone believe that Marvel will fire its authors and close up shop if it can't prevent little Johnny from pretending to be Wolverine online?

When will the "content" industry begin to recognize that there are long-term rewards for letting fans be fans? A fan's gratitude and loyalty lasts a lot longer than the judgment-money from shutting down the playground.

Deeplinks Topics

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

Federal appeals court rules that sheriff’s threats against credit card companies violate the First Amendment

Dec 1 @ 7:54pm

The TPP negotiations have ended but the fight to stop it is far from over. Here's how we're going to defeat it:

Dec 1 @ 5:14pm

First-ever complete unmasking of FBI national security letter shows scope of spying, need for NSL challenges:

Dec 1 @ 3:59pm
JavaScript license information