October 9, 2007 | By Fred von Lohmann

Capitol v. Thomas: The Key Appeal Issue

In the upcoming appeal of the $222,000 judgment against Ms. Jammie Thomas, the outcome will likely turn on Jury Instruction #15, which equates "making available" with "distributing" a copyrighted work. If the appeals court rejects that jury instruction, the verdict against Ms. Thomas would have to be thrown out and the case re-tried.

Here's the instruction that was read to the jury:

Jury Instruction #15: The act of making copyrighted sound recordings available for electronic distribution on a peer-to-peer network, without license from the copyright owners, violates the copyright owners' exclusive right of distribution, regardless of whether actual distribution has been shown.

There are two distinct things wrong with this instruction.

First, the "distribution right" set out in Section 106(3) of the Copyright Act simply does not extend to Internet transmissions. It may sound odd, but "distribution" as defined in the Copyright Act requires that a physical object change hands (remember, this is a law that was written in 1976). EFF laid out this argument in its amicus brief in the Elektra v. Barker case, building on a 2001 article by University of Texas copyright law professor R. Anthony Reese.

Second, even if the "distribution right" reached Internet transmissions, a copyright owner must prove that a distribution actually took place (i.e., that someone actually downloaded from Ms. Thomas' computer). As a result, Jury Instruction #15 is wrong when it asserts that the record companies can prevail "regardless of whether actual distribution has been shown." For more on this issue, read the amicus brief filed by CCIA in Elektra v. Barker, as well as the 2005 ruling by Judge Patel in the Napster case.

For the full battery of arguments on both sides, take a look at the briefs filed in Elektra v. Barker (amicus briefs were filed by EFF, CCIA, RIAA, MPAA, Dept. of Justice). The court heard argument in that case back in January 2007, but still has not issued a decision on the "making available" issue.


Deeplinks Topics

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

This week's @PlanetMoney podcast explores the shocking levels of secrecy around trade deals like TPP https://eff.org/r.aas6

Jun 30 @ 4:49pm

Secret FISA Court gives the NSA a temporary extension on spying on our phone records: https://eff.org/r.yqa3

Jun 30 @ 4:37pm

Here’s how Computerworld covered EFF’s birth 25 years ago https://eff.org/r.a34f

Jun 30 @ 1:28pm
JavaScript license information