CDA230

Nemet Chevrolet, LTD. v. Consumeraffairs.com, Inc., 591 F.3d 250 (4th Cir. 2009)

Type of online publisher: 
Consumeraffairs.com, forum for product and business reviews
Publisher's Role in Third Party Content: 
Provided a forum for customers to post reviews of products and businesses
CDA ยง 230 applicable?: 
Yes

Consumeraffairs.com provided a forum for customers to post reviews of products and businesses. Internet users posted allegedly false negative reviews of the plaintiff's dealership and the used cars they obtained there. Nemet Chevrolet alleged that Consumeraffairs solicited posts from users, put them in particular categories, and edited them. The court held that this behavior would not remove the Consumeraffairs from CDA 230 immunity because it does not turn them into a content creator. Nemet also alleged that Consumeraffairs fabricated reviews on their site. This would make CDA 230 not apply, because Consumeraffairs would be the author, however the court found that the allegation was conclusory and insufficient to go forward.

Key quotes:

Nemet fails to make any cognizable argument as to how a website operator who contacts a potential user with questions thus "develops" or "creates" the website content. Assuming it to be true that Consumeraffairs.com contacted the consumers to ask some unknown question, this bare allegation proves nothing as to Nemet's claim Consumeraffairs.com is an information content provider.

Court Opinion Document: 
Jurisdiction: 

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

Next Wed 6/29 we'll discuss how to fight surveillance, defend privacy, build the digital rights movement. Join us! https://eff.org/2016-06-EFA

Jun 26 @ 9:02am

Check out the Young Journalist Contest at HOPE: http://www.2600.com/content/e...

Jun 24 @ 1:25pm

Former inmate who served 11 months in solitary for an online rap video tells his story to @MarshallProj https://www.themarshallprojec...

Jun 24 @ 11:08am
JavaScript license information