December 13, 2007 | By Richard Esguerra

Senators Press Reid to Choose "No" on Telecom Immunity

Last month, the Senate Judiciary Committee passed a surveillance bill that did not grant immunity to lawbreaking telecoms. At the time, many predicted a bitter showdown, because a different congressional committee had previously passed a bill that granted immunity. That showdown begins now, as the Senate Majority Leader prepares to choose a version for the full Senate to vote upon, setting the stage for a broader battle between granting immunity or rightfully letting the cases against lawbreaking telecoms continue unassailed.

To clarify, the most recent proposal by the Senate Judiciary Committee does not include telecom immunity and calls for court oversight of spying operations. The older proposal by the Senate Intelligence Committee does include telecom immunity and has weaker civil liberties protections overall. Though both bills have flaws, the version reported by the Senate Judiciary Committee is better in its approach to effective foreign surveillance and protecting Americans' civil liberties.

Ultimately, it falls to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid to choose which version is brought on the Senate floor -- this is why 14 Senators have sent a letter to Sen. Reid, asking him to start with the Senate Judiciary version. In the letter, the Senators express a desire to start with a bill that was crafted more openly, that features more court oversight, and that does not provide immunity for telecoms believed to have cooperated in warrantless wiretapping.

The Senate may vote on surveillance legislation as early as next week, so the fight begins here. Stay tuned for more updates and actions you can take to help prevent the Senate from immunizing the telecoms, potentially interrupting the judicial process for millions of Americans affected by warrantless spying.


Deeplinks Topics

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

EFF will speak at Black Hat Briefings on both government surveillance and export controls. https://eff.org/r.nilc #BHUSA

Jul 6 @ 7:14pm

Massive leak of Hacking Team docs exposes the firm selling spyware to authoritarian governments: https://eff.org/r.f6bu

Jul 6 @ 4:40pm

Newest leak of TPP's IP chapter reveals how countries are converging on anti-user copyright takedown rules: https://eff.org/r.jedp

Jul 6 @ 3:40pm
JavaScript license information