Burd v. Cole

On June 29 2006 EFF filed to block an Oklahoma school superintendent's attempt to unmask the identities of a local website's operator and all registered users. On July 17 2006 three days before a court hearing on EFF's motion to quash Plaintiff dismissed his case.

The superintendent has sued Internet users who criticized him on the website's message board. In its motion to quash EFF argues that the plaintiff's overbroad subpoena seeking to identify the site's operator and users violates First Amendment protections for anonymous speech and association.

"Anonymity is critical to public discourse and fundamental to a free society allowing speakers to offer diverse views without fear of undue reprisal " said EFF Staff Attorney Corynne McSherry. "There is now clear judicial consensus that subpoenas to identify anonymous speakers must be carefully scrutinized."

In recent months EFF lawyers have represented or provided amicus support in anonymity cases in California Colorado and Delaware. In the latter case Doe v. Cahill EFF helped successfully defend a Delaware blogger who had criticized a member of the town council. The case resulted in the first state supreme court decision confirming the First Amendment right to remain anonymous until a litigant can demonstrate a legitimate claim.

"Litigants must not be permitted to abuse the judicial process to identity anonymous individuals who have simply created a forum for critical comments or made statements a plaintiff dislikes " said EFF Staff Attorney Matt Zimmerman. "Speech critical of public officials—made anonymously or not—enjoys an extremely high level of legal protection."

Outcome: Case dismissed and anonymity of speaker protected.

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

Massive leak of Hacking Team docs exposes the firm selling spyware to authoritarian governments: https://eff.org/r.f6bu

Jul 6 @ 4:40pm

Newest leak of TPP's IP chapter reveals how countries are converging on anti-user copyright takedown rules: https://eff.org/r.jedp

Jul 6 @ 3:40pm

MasterCard and Visa are shutting down payments to Backpage. Here's why that's bad for free speech online: https://eff.org/r.v395

Jul 6 @ 3:11pm
JavaScript license information