EFFector Vol. 16, No. 37 January 12, 2004
A Publication of the Electronic Frontier Foundation ISSN 1062-9424
In the 276th Issue of EFFector:
- EFF Defends Right to Own Smart Card Technology
- Californians: Come to an Important E-Voting Meeting
- EFF Secures Protection for ReplayTV Clients
- EFF Comments on Intel's Draft Policy for LaGrande "Trusted Computing" Initiative
- EFF Helps eVisa Win Ninth Circuit Appeal, Right to Use English Language
- Nominate a Pioneer for EFF's 2004 Pioneer Awards
- New EFF T-Shirts, Hot Off the Presses
- Deep Links (15): What Happens in Vegas, Stays...in an FBI Dossier?
- EFF Court Docket: 02.03.04 - MGM v. Grokster; 02.09.04 - OPG v. Diebold
- Staff Calendar: 01.13.04 - Wendy Seltzer speaks at IDLELO First African Conference on the Digital Commons, Cape Town, South Africa; 01.22.04 - Fred von Lohmann speaks at "Washington in the West" Conference, Long Beach, CA
EFF Defends Right to Own Smart Card Technology
Files Amicus Brief On Behalf of Public in DirecTV Appeal
San Francisco - Defending the right to own and experiment with general-purpose technology, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) today filed a friend-of-the court brief in an Eleventh Circuit appeals case that will determine whether satellite giant DirecTV can sue "smart card" technology owner Mike Treworgy for simply possessing hardware that enables him to program electronic smart cards.
Smart cards are computer devices that have a multitude of legitimate purposes, which can also be used illegally to intercept satellite signals. DirecTV believes that mere purchase of smart card programming hardware should constitute proof that the hardware is being used illegally.
"Computer researchers, network administrators, engineers and others are using smart card technology in ways that are perfectly legal, yet DirecTV would have the courts adopt a theory of guilt-by-purchase," said EFF Staff Attorney Jason Schultz. "This is not only grossly unjust, it also threatens to scare legitimate innovators away from an extremely promising branch of technology."
In the lower court ruling, U.S. District Court Judge John E. Steele agreed to dismiss DirecTV's possession claim in its lawsuit against Mr. Treworgy, finding that the company does not have the authority to decide who can legally own the technology. DirecTV appealed, making this case the first such dispute in the country to reach the appellate court level.
"DirecTV is threatening innocent researchers, hobbyists and others who have never intercepted a single minute of DirecTV's transmissions," added Schultz. "This cannot be what the law intends, and we hope the Eleventh Circuit will send a strong message to that effect."
DirecTV has sent over 150,000 letters demanding settlements of $3,500 and up from individuals who purchased smart card technology. The company has followed this up with over 15,000 lawsuits claiming that mere possession of these devices is unlawful. As a result, those caught in DirecTV's dragnet have been forced to choose between paying for a lawyer and paying for a settlement.
In response to the lawsuits, EFF has partnered with Stanford's Center for Internet and Society to establish DirecTVdefense.org, a website aimed at helping innocent people defend their right to own and use smart card technology.
- For the full media release
- EFF Amicus Brief in DirectTV Inc. v. Mike Treworgy (PDF)
- DirecTV Defense Website Aids Users Caught in Legal Dragnet
Californians: Come to an Important E-Voting Meeting
Sacramento - On January 15, the California Voting Systems and Procedures Panel will hold a public meeting on the certification of Diebold e-voting machines. In December, a state-wide audit found that Diebold installed uncertified computer code in all 17 counties that use its machines. This practice undermines the security and accountability of our elections. Come let your government know that this isn't acceptable:
When: 10 a.m., January 15, 2004
Where: 1500 11th Street
1st Floor - Auditorium
Sacramento, CA 95814
Make sure that concerned citizens outnumber voting machine vendors at this important meeting!
- Meeting notice and agenda (PDF)
- Wired article: "E-Voting Undermined by Sloppiness"
- EFF's e-voting resources
EFF Secures Protection for ReplayTV Clients
Hollywood Promises Not to Sue Consumer Plaintiffs
A federal court ruled on Friday to end a case brought by five ReplayTV digital video recorder (DVR) owners after 28 entertainment companies promised not to sue them for copyright infringement for using the "commercial advance" or "send show" features of their DVRs.
"Skipping commercials is not illegal and neither is sending television shows from your home to your office, as one of our clients does," said EFF Staff Attorney Gwen Hinze. "We're pleased that we were able to protect our clients against unjustifiable copyright claims for exercising their fair use rights."
EFF had asked the court to give affirmative relief to all owners of ReplayTV DVRs with commercial skipping and "send show" features. The court declined to do so on the grounds that the entertainment companies promised not to sue here and had indicated no intention to sue any of the other owners. The court did, however, leave open the possibility of relief in the event that the entertainment companies change their position and seek to sue ReplayTV owners.
- For the full media release
- ReplayTV Users Seek Class Action in "Digital Betamax" Case
- Newmark v. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. case archive
EFF Comments on Intel's Draft Policy for LaGrande "Trusted Computing" Initiative
EFF has filed comments responding to Intel's draft policy on privacy and owner choice and control issues in the company's "trusted computing" LaGrande Technology initiative. Our conclusion: LaGrande Technology has the potential to be abused to diminish computer owners' choice, control and privacy, and while the draft policy sets forth useful best practices, it cannot prevent these abuses.
- EFF's Comments on LaGrande Technology Policy on Owner/User Choice and Control
- Trusted Computing: Promise and Risk
EFF Helps eVisa Win Ninth Circuit Appeal, Right to Use English Language
On December 22, Evisa.com won its appeal to the Ninth Circuit over whether its domain name dilutes Visa's trademark for credit cards, keeping the word "visa" in the dictionary (and DNS servers) for now.
"Visa is a generic word used throughout the world to describe foreign travel and was used long before it became a brand name for credit cards," said EFF Staff Attorney Jason Schultz. "The Court of Appeals wisely rejected Visa's attempt to monpolize use of the word 'visa' in a domain name without further proof of harm to Visa's business."
Nominate a Pioneer for EFF's 2004 Pioneer Awards
EFF established the Pioneer Awards to recognize leaders on the electronic frontier who are extending freedom and innovation in the realm of information technology. This is your opportunity to nominate a deserving individual or group to receive a Pioneer Award for 2004.
The International Pioneer Awards nominations are open both to individuals and organizations from any country.
All nominations are reviewed by a panel of judges chosen for their knowledge of the technical, legal, and social issues associated with information technology.
This year's award ceremony will be held in Berkeley, California, in conjunction with the Computers, Freedom and Privacy conference (CFP), which takes place in mid-April.
How to Nominate Someone for a 2004 Pioneer Award:
You may send as many nominations as you wish, but please use one email per nomination. Please submit your entries via email to firstname.lastname@example.org We will accept nominations until February 1, 2004.
Simply tell us:
- The name of the nominee,
- the phone number or email address at which the nominee can be reached, and, most importantly,
- why you feel the nominee deserves the award.
There are no specific categories for the EFF Pioneer Awards, but the following guidelines apply:
- The nominees must have contributed substantially to the health, growth, accessibility, or freedom of computer-based communications.
- The contribution may be technical, social, economic, or cultural.
- Nominations may be of individuals, systems, or organizations in the private or public sectors.
- Nominations are open to all (other than current members of EFF's staff and board or this year's award judges), and you may nominate more than one recipient. You may also nominate yourself or your organization.
- To be valid, all nominations must contain your reason, however brief, for nominating the individual or organization and a means of contacting the nominee. In addition, while anonymous nominations will be accepted, ideally we'd like to contact the nominating parties in case we need further information.
- Persons or representatives of organizations receiving an EFF Pioneer Award will be invited to attend the ceremony at EFF's expense.
New EFF T-shirts, Hot Off the Presses
Been meaning to join EFF? Now is a good time: we've just received a new shipment of t-shirts. Check out the cool new design and join us at the "Benefactor" level or higher. We'll send you a t-shirt to wear with pride!
Deep Links features noteworthy news items from around the Internet.
- Advertising? On
the Web? Genius!
A suit against The New York Times, Travelocity and others claims that their use of a number of popular online ad formats violates patents held by an Illinois company.
- RIAA Holds Post-Holiday
Settlement Sale (USA Today)
It settled ten more file-sharing suits, but one party paid about $2.10 per song while two others paid nothing at all.
- Piracy by
Numbers? Maybe Not.
Peter Martin analyzes the recording industry's numbers on music piracy and concludes that the industry simply hasn't connected the dots.
- Consumer Group Sues
Over Copy-protected CDs
Deluged with complaints about CDs that won't play in car stereos and computers, a European consumer watchdog group has decided to sue four of the world's biggest record labels.
- Michael Moore Endorses File
Sharing for His Movies (BoingBoing weblog)
Could Mr. Moore do for P2P what Mr. Rogers did for the VCR?
- What Happens in Vegas, Stays...in an FBI Dossier?
The FBI obtained personal information on about a quarter of a million visitors to Las Vegas this holiday season. By our count, one Orange Alert = a violation of privacy for nearly 1 in 1,000 Americans:
Las Vegas Review-Journal
- Rating the Privacy Czar at
(Business Week; registration unfortunately required.)
Nuala Kelly is taking positive steps toward more responsible information policies.
- The Night the
Websites Went Out in North America
A PA state law forced MCI to block over 1 million innocuous websites from all of its North American subscribers.
- RIAA Killed
the Net Radio Stars
The contentious webcasting royalty arbitration process that has already claimed a number of victims in the nascent net radio industry will soon begin another round.
- An Open
Letter to the Next Head of the MPAA
Wired's editor-in-chief has a few pointers for the anteValenti.
- Learning to Count, South
(Miami Herald; registration unfortunately required.)
A recent Florida election conducted using e-voting machines doesn't add up.
- E-Voting Firm Hacked.
VoteHere, a Bellevue-based voting security company, has had its web server compromised.
- Vitamin RFID Coming
to a Pharmacy Near You
(United Press International; registration unfortunately required.)
Warning: some patients may experience serious side effects, including shortness of breath and a lack of privacy.
- How the Net
Online Journalism Review on the evolving tactics of net-savvy political activists.
The High Tech
Annalee Newitz on an emerging class of unlikely outlaws.
EFF Court Docket
- February 3 - MGM v. Grokster
U.S. Court of Appeals
- February 9 - OPG v. Diebold
U.S. District Court, Northern California
280 South 1st street
San Jose, CA.
For a complete listing of EFF speaking engagements (with locations and times), please visit: http://www.eff.org/calendar/
- January 13 - Wendy Seltzer speaks at IDLELO First
African Conference on the Digital Commons Cape Town, South Africa
9:00 a.m. - 10:00 a.m.
- January 22 - Fred von Lohmann speaks at
"Washington in the West" Conference Long Beach, CA.
11:40 a.m. - 12:40 p.m.
EFFector is published by:
The Electronic Frontier Foundation
454 Shotwell Street
San Francisco CA 94110-1914 USA
+1 415 436 9333 (voice)
+1 415 436 9993 (fax)
Donna Wentworth, Web Writer/Activist
To Join EFF online, or make an additional donation, go to:
Reproduction of this publication in electronic media is encouraged. Signed articles do not necessarily represent the views of EFF. To reproduce signed articles individually, please contact the authors for their express permission. Press releases and EFF announcements and articles may be reproduced individually at will.
To change your address or other information, please visit: http://action.eff.org/subscribe/
If you have already subscribed to the EFF Action Center, please visit: http://action.eff.org/login.asp/
To unsubscribe from the EFFector mailing list, send an email to email@example.com with the word "Remove" in the subject.
(Please ask firstname.lastname@example.org to manually remove you from the list if this does not work for you for some reason.)
Back issues are available at:
You can also get the latest issue of EFFector via the Web at:
Please send any questions or comments to email@example.com