December 4, 2009 | By Ed Bayley

Terms of (Ab)use: Are Terms of Service Enforceable?

Terms of Service image

In the first of a series of white papers on Terms of Service (TOS) issues, EFF today released The Clicks That Bind: Ways Users “Agree” to Online Terms of Service. The paper aims to answer a fundamental question: when do these ubiquitous TOS agreements actually become binding contracts? We discuss how courts have reacted to efforts by service providers to enforce TOS, and suggest best practices for service providers to follow in presenting terms to a user and for seeking his or her agreement to them.

The white paper examines both clickwrap agreements&#8212whereby service providers require the user to click an “I Agree” button next to the terms&#8212and browsewrap agreements&#8212whereby service providers try to characterize one's continued use of the website as constituting “agreement” to a posted set of terms. While neither method automatically creates enforceable contracts, some presentations may still be upheld even if the user never actually reads and understands the terms. The key is whether the service provider allows the user reasonable notice and opportunity to review the terms before using the website or service.

Of course, just because a TOS creates an enforceable agreement, does not mean that every provision of the TOS will be enforced by a court. In our next white paper, we'll examine which particular provisions are most unfair to consumers, including provisions that have aroused the skepticism of courts and regulators.


Deeplinks Topics

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

Los Angeles Times endorses CalECPA: "These safeguards are overdue in an increasingly interconnected world…” https://eff.org/r.7dpt

Sep 3 @ 1:36pm

A dark corner of the TPP threatens to exacerbate the orphan works crisis. Op-ed in the Washington Post: https://eff.org/r.ar5w

Sep 3 @ 1:03pm

Going to @DragonCon? Here are four types of surveillance tech that police are using in the Atlanta area. https://eff.org/r.a4yn

Sep 3 @ 8:20am
JavaScript license information