October 4, 2006 | By Kevin Bankston

Federal Judge Refuses to Dismiss PATRIOT Act Case (Finally!)

After a wait of nearly three years, Judge Hood in the Eastern District of Michigan finally ruled yesterday on the government's request that the court dismiss a lawsuit brought by a group of Muslim and Arab-American associations challenging the constitutionality of PATRIOT Act Section 215. As you may recall, Section 215 authorizes the government to obtain a secret order from the FISA court demanding business records or any other information that investigators think is relevant to a terrorism investigation. The court's decision? Motion denied!

Says the court:

Plaintiffs have alleged that they and their members? right to speech and association are being threatened by Section 215. They fear that the Government has already obtained information or will be obtaining information by way of a Section 215 order. Plaintiffs and their members fear that the information contained in Plaintiffs? records are subject to a 215 order. Plaintiffs have alleged that their members are afraid to attend mosque, practice their religion, and express their opinions on religion and political issues. Plaintiffs? members are afraid to obtain services from the human services organizations for fear that any information obtained by the organization can be obtained by the Government. Plaintiffs have shown threats of present injury sufficient to satisfy constitutional standing requirements on their First Amendment claims. Defendants? Motion to Dismiss based on lack of standing on Plaintiffs? First Amendment claims is denied.

You can read the court's decision here. For a refresher on what Section 215 is and why it stinks, check out EFF's analysis or read the amicus brief in the case that was submitted by EFF and other free speech organizations.


Deeplinks Topics

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

Unless stopped, European user content sites may be forced to do revenue-sharing deals with entertainment companies https://www.eff.org/deeplinks...

Aug 26 @ 3:52pm

Leaked European copyright proposal would cause massive changes to Internet platforms and news sites as we know them https://www.eff.org/deeplinks...

Aug 26 @ 1:06pm

Research universities are supposed to drive innovation. When they sell patents to trolls, they do just the opposite. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks...

Aug 26 @ 12:41pm
JavaScript license information