Vernor v. Autodesk

This case tests whether the "first sale doctrine" in copyright law which makes it legal to resell lend or give away books CDs DVDs and software that you own will survive in the digital age of "licensed" content.

Timothy Vernor is an online software reseller who tried to auction four packages of Autodesk's AutoCAD software on eBay. Autodesk threatened Mr. Vernor with a copyright lawsuit claiming that its software is only "licensed " never sold. With the assistance of the public interest litigators at Public Citizen Vernor filed suit in Seattle against Autodesk asking the court to clarify his right to resell the AutoCAD software packages. He prevailed before the district court in 2009 prompting Autodesk to appeal.

Autodesk's position is that its software is "licensed " rather than sold and thus that the first sale doctrine doesn't apply (it only applies to copies you "own " not those you merely lease). If that's right then it would violate copyright law lend or resell it without Autodesk's permission.

In an amicus curiae brief filed with the court of appeals EFF—joined by the Consumer Federation of America the American Library Association Association of Research Libraries Association of College and Research Libraries U.S. Public Interest Research Group and Public Knowledge—argued that copyright owners should not be able to trump the first sale doctrine by using a few "magic words" in a "license agreement."

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

Why the Senate's excuses to reauthorize Section 215 are wrong: https://eff.org/r.4p40

May 22 @ 10:48am

Open data fail: @CalAGHarris locks down wiretap and other criminal justice data in unwieldy format https://eff.org/r.mmf1 #foiafriday

May 22 @ 10:03am

Computer crime and copyright laws silence helpful hackers, making us all less safe, explains @Hacker0x01: https://eff.org/r.vo5f

May 21 @ 5:02pm
JavaScript license information