Cindy Cohn, executive director of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, says the appeals court ruling is "a great and welcome decision and it ought to make Congress pause to consider whether the small changes it’s making in the USA Freedom Act are really sufficient.”

Cohn participated in oral arguments supporting Klayman’s win and has been involved with a third appeal against the collection in the 9th Circuit. She's pleased the decision “rips apart the government’s interpretation” of words such as “relevance” and “investigation” under Section 215.

“I don’t think that Congress alone giving an endorsement to these words would be sufficient under the court’s analysis,” she says. “I think Congress would actually have to say very clearly what it was doing in order to get over that and then the question is whether that would survive [constitutional analysis].”

Thursday, May 7, 2015
U.S. News & World Report

Related Issues