April 26, 2007 | By Peter Eckersley

The Great Firewall of Utah (and Banning Open Wi-Fi)

The Utah legislature has been considering a proposal that would require the state's ISPs to ensure that minors are unable to access explicit material on the Internet [1] [2]. The scheme would also make open wireless networks illegal (!) unless they are restricted to only allow connections on certain, censored, "community ports".

Giving ISPs the responsibility and incentives to censor a paricular subset of the web is precisely the same architecture that the Chinese Communist Party uses for their "Great Fireall of China". The communists use it to filter news and political information as well as porn — but in neither case is it particularly effective. Users who are either knowledgeable or motivated quickly learn that there are easy ways around these filters.

The absurd Utah proposal has been pushed by the CP80 Foundation, which pedals fanatasies of a world where certain TCP ports (80, for instance) are free of any material that they consider "indecent". The group is fronted by SCO Chairman Ralph Yarro. Yes, that SCO.

The chance that a state or even federal statute could (practically or constitutionally) prevent sexually explicit content from being transmitted through port 80 is approximately zero point zero zero zero percent. The chance that politicians could pass foolish laws that cause needless headaches and court battles for ISPs and users, however, is significantly higher.

Deeplinks Topics

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

The JPEG format succeeded because it was free, open, and interoperable. Why ruin a good thing with DRM? https://eff.org/r.6riw

Oct 13 @ 12:38pm

Join us in celebrating women's achievements in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics: https://eff.org/lovelaceday2015

Oct 13 @ 12:36pm

Listen to EFF researcher @Maassive discuss newly signed California privacy laws on @kpbsmidday, live at 12:20pm PT https://eff.org/r.rg06

Oct 13 @ 11:46am
JavaScript license information