July 22, 2004 | By Donna Wentworth

Hollywood (Finally) Turns on TiVo, Part II

Susan Crawford, responding to the Jonathan Krim article we mentioned earlier today about TiVo and the FCC's broadcast flag mandate (PDF):

The flag was supposed to be about indiscriminate online distribution. TiVo is trying to provide a device that allows 10 people within a personal network to copy TiVo-ed shows onto their PCs. It's perfectly secure. It's just not quite constrained enough for the studios.

And Hollywood is asking [pdf] the FCC to make sure that this TiVo functionality never reaches consumers.

This desperate quest for control, using the FCC as an apparently willing tool, will end its first stage next week. The rumor is that Real and MSN have already caved in to the studios. Only TiVo is still fighting.

The flag proceeding has convinced me that FCC is capable of almost anything. That's why it seems important to let FCC know just how hard making rules about IP-enabled services will be.


Deeplinks Topics

Stay in Touch

NSA Spying

EFF is leading the fight against the NSA's illegal mass surveillance program. Learn more about what the program is, how it works, and what you can do.

Follow EFF

This photo may violate Copyright Directive restrictions on media BEING RIPPED. #EFFintheWild https://eff.org/powerup

Dec 2 @ 2:03pm

EFF hat on a fluffy friend in Hyde Park, London. #EFFintheWild https://eff.org/powerup

Dec 2 @ 1:45pm

Online censorship bums Gracie out. That and running out of treats. #EFFintheWild https://eff.org/powerup

Dec 2 @ 1:21pm
JavaScript license information